It was a cold winter Sunday. I was happy to be at my home church, nestled cozily in a back pew. My former pastor began his sermon. I was engaged. So much so that I began to recognize some of the statements and ideas he was presenting. I had heard this before. It was from a book I had just read the previous summer. Yes, yes! I loved that book. I couldn’t wait to have a follow-up conversation with my pastor about it. I was completely tracking with him. I couldn’t wait for him to reference the book at some point. It was undeniably the author’s ideas, but before I knew it, the sermon came to a close.
No reference.
I sat in that formerly cozy pew, feeling a bit more uncomfortable.
“Why wouldn’t he state his source?
Why would he act like those ideas were his own?
It would’ve been so easy to state a source.
This feels bad, but I love my pastor.
I know he’s a good guy.”
My thoughts trampled over one another. It wasn’t long before I determined that addressing this with him could put a strain on our relationship.
And as fate would have it, the very next day he called to ask me to consider being his co-host on our church’s YouTube Q&A channel. As you can imagine, my concerns had not only flown out the window with this flattering invitation; they might as well have been in outer space.
This was five years ago now, but when I think back, I wonder, why? Why did I not say anything to him?
Here are the best reasons I can come up with:
- My pastor served, preached, and seemingly gave his life for the service of the church. I was convinced that he was a man who took God’s word seriously. I thought he cared about my family. He was always kind and checking in when we bumped into each other. My brain had made a pact: he was undeniably above reproach. When I saw him behave otherwise, my brain seemed to fog up and not be able to digest what I had just witnessed.
- I didn’t want to have an awkward conversation. Could you imagine just casually mentioning this to someone? “Hey, I read the book you quoted, but you didn’t cite your source. Are you guilty of plagiarism?” I could not fathom this conversation being anything other than humiliating. And with my deeply rooted people-pleasing skills, there was no way I was going to put him through that.
- I did not want my life to change in any way. I didn’t want my church to change. I didn’t want to make waves. I didn’t want to be a stick in the mud. I wanted to be liked. I wanted my pastor to know, “Hey, I’m on your side”. I didn’t want our family treated differently just because we had a concern.
- Sadly, I silenced the Holy Spirit. Plain and simple. When the internal alarms were going off, I gathered as many justifications as I could think of and smothered the voice of the Spirit.
Recently, a well-known Canadian apologist, Wesley Huff, publicly apologized for plagiarizing. After briefly dismissing the multiple whistleblowers who had been coming forward with concerns, he decided to own up to his actions and temporarily step down from his VP position with Apologetics Canada. The Roys Report does an excellent job of describing the details of his situation, but here’s a small excerpt from his recent apology:
”I have plagiarized the work of others. This was wrong, and it was sinful. Over the years, I allowed myself to develop justifications for my actions, minimizing their seriousness and, at times, even pushing them so far from my mind that I failed to reckon with what I had done. These patterns have affected far more of my work than I ever wanted to acknowledge.”
His statement as a whole seems genuine, and I do applaud him for acknowledging the extent of his wrongful actions. He seems to take responsibility as a whole, not just in parts, and that is a rare occurrence nowadays.
But what I found even more shocking was the response of self-professed Christians. Here are some comments on Julie Roy’s Facebook page where she commends Wesley for his response regarding the matter.
“Wes Huff is a Godly man and a good teacher. Whether or not he properly cited his sources in some of his earlier writings is of little concern. This is being blown way out of proportion. I pray for Wes and I support him fully. Howerton is an amazing pastor too, your criticism of him here is unfounded.”
”How much of any sermon, political speech, or FB post is truly 100% original. I listen to Josh weekly in sermons and podcast. He regularly pauses to attribute a comment or story to others. How ridiculous it would be to expect a speaker to site every comment, story or illustration if not an original thought or idea. I once heard a preacher say to young pastors, “if my bullet fits in your gun, go ahead and shoot it”.”
“Wes is great he made a mistake 10 years ago and were letting it go.”
What I find profoundly interesting is that even when the man is admitting to committing a sin that has serious implications, many assumed Christians are speaking up to defend the very behavior he is in the process of repenting of.
As I have stated earlier, I was guilty of choosing intentional blindness with my own church leader. But I do think if someone had spoken up with the same concern or if my pastor had chosen to expose his sin and repent, I hope that I would not defend my pastor out of his repentance. I hope that I would not remedy the shame I felt for him by discouraging his choice to become right with the Lord. There is nothing honorable or fruitful about telling your brother or sister in Christ that their sin is no big deal. I have witnessed the devastating consequences this can have on the individual, on their families, on the church, and on outsiders who witness this justification game.
Is forgiveness freely given for those who repent? Yes! So why the need to minimize what is clearly wrong?
There is a ferocious enemy that would love nothing more than for these highly respected leaders to go on for years without accountability, so that one day when they are exposed, they can make the claim that the entire gospel is a fraud.
I want to close with some more words from Wes…
“My heart has always been to tell people about Jesus, to share the gospel, and to help others discover the beauty and richness of the Bible and its history. But having a good desire does not excuse the ways I have fallen short in pursuing it. I have clearly failed to uphold the standards of integrity that I have encouraged others to value. That failure is mine, and I take responsibility for it. One of the things that grieves me most is the reality that, through my own actions, I have undeniably brought reproach upon the very gospel I have spent so much of my life seeking to proclaim. The truth of the gospel is never served by dishonesty in the way we communicate it. I cannot justify my actions by appealing to my intentions.”
Have you ever dismissed blatant wrong doing by someone who you loved or respected? Why do you think you did that? Do you think plagiarism is a serious problem in the church? Or do you think it’s being taken too seriously?
